29 Brandon Phillips
28 Jim Maloney
27 Ernie Lombardi
26 Barry Larkin
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
25 Tommy Helms
24 Johnny Cueto
23 Ken Griffey
22 Jose Rijo
21 Tom Browning
20 Bernie Carbo
19 Aroldis Chapman
18 Cesar Geronimo
17 Joe Nuxhall
16 Davey Concepcion
15 Don Gullett
14 Lee May
13 Eric Davis
12 Vada Pinson
11 Chris Sabo
10 Johnny Vander Meer
9 Ted Kluszewski
8 Bobby Tolan
7 Joey Votto
6 George Foster
5 Frank Robinson
4 Joe Morgan
3 Tony Perez
2 Johnny Bench
1 Pete Rose
This list does not include Sparky Anderson (since he was a manager), Tom Seaver (since he'll always be a Met), Bronson Aroyo (since he'll always be a Red Sock), or Ken Griffey, Jr. (since he's still on my all-time injured reserve list) -- despite my liking them each very much.
Active players are in bold. (N.B.: Joey Votto has a viable shot to break well into the top 5 by the time his career comes to an end.)